10.0

really awful
Crashes / Fires:
2 / 0
Injuries / Deaths:
1 / 0
Average Mileage:
88,910 miles

About These NHTSA Complaints:

The NHTSA is the US gov't agency tasked with vehicle safety. Complaints can be spread across multiple & redundant categories, & are not organized by problem. See the Back button — blue bar at the very top of the page — to explore more.

Get notified about new defects, investigations, recalls & lawsuits for the 2010 Subaru Legacy:

Unsubscribe any time. We don't sell/share your email.

« Read the previous 20 complaints

problem #20

Jun 012018

Legacy

  • 93,334 miles
Torque converter problem: I went to bob baker Subaru carlsbad, ca this 12:10pm, 06/04/18. I told the services guy that my engine shut off after step on brakes at low speed. I researched and downloaded the design problem notice from Subaru, and he said the need to do more testing on my vehicle. I was waiting until 5pm and he finally told me that was it. I was represented the notice that came from Subaru company. Why he was still hesitate not to fix immediately after I presented the notice. I believe that they had a lot of customers complaint before??

- San Diego, CA, USA

problem #19

Nov 022017

Legacy

  • 153,000 miles
Transmission has an issue with lock-up type torque converter where the vehicle stalls at stops. Took the vehicle to lawrence Subaru dealer in hanover, pa, dealer refused to fix under current warranty citing no issue with vehicle.

- Fairfield, PA, USA

problem #18

Sep 122017

Legacy

  • 145,000 miles
Car drops RPM and stumbles to almost stalling during breaking at city speeds also does the same in low speed reverse situation like parking. Dash lights up but no code stored. This is the third time this issue has presented itself. I spoke to a dealer reference the reverse issue and was told that there was nothing wrong with the car. Subaru claims to be one of the safest vehicles on the road? this is not safe. The chance of being rear ended at highway speed could be deadly!

- Belton, TX, USA

problem #17

Jul 082017

Legacy

  • 89,700 miles
The contact owns a 2010 Subaru Legacy. While driving 65 mph, the vehicle made a loud grinding noise while attempting to downshift as well as upshift gears. The contact tried to reverse the vehicle, but it continued to make a grinding noise. Lou fusz Subaru of St peters, Missouri was made aware of the failure and stated that the vehicle needed a new transmission. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was not made aware of the issue. The failure mileage was approximately 89,700.

- Saint Charles, MO, USA

problem #16

Jul 082017

Legacy

  • miles
The torque converter is locking up and not releasing, which causes the car to stall at random times. There are times where you may be on a hill and the car stalls. This is very dangerous in atlanta traffic. Subaru of America released a service bulletin to repair the issue at the driver's expense. On 6/21/17 they extended the warranties for the cvt transmission, but that did not cover the torque converter issue. I feel I shouldn't have to pay for the repairs since this is a mechanical fault on Subaru's end. What does it take for them to realize that they should be fixing these issues and assume responsibility for this" a car to stall in the middle of an intersection and the driver gets hit"

- Norcross, GA, USA

problem #15

May 012015

Legacy

  • 100,000 miles
Stopping vehicle quickly and engine shudders and stalls at any speed. My car has 120K miles and has been doing this since just under 100K miles

- Amesbury, MA, USA

problem #14

Apr 082017

Legacy

  • 86,000 miles
Car dies when hard stopping. I took it to midas and was diagnosed with torque converter lock up. Took into Subaru and was told needs a new transmission.

- El Dorado Hills, CA, USA

problem #13

Mar 202017

Legacy

  • miles
When coming to an abrupt stop, the engine sputters, stalls and dies. This is due to the torque converter locking up and killing the engine. Sometimes the stop does not have to be abrupt. Subaru needs to make this a recall and pay for the repairs.

- Bowling Green, KY, USA

problem #12

Feb 162017

Legacy

  • 188,250 miles
Per service bulletin # 16-90-13, the car will stall when coming to an abrupt stop. Part of the time, the vehicle will stall when coming to a normal stop as well. This happened once while city driving when a light went from red to green as we were approaching. We were down to under 5 mph and went to accelerate again to continue with the flow of traffic. Before I could release the brake, the car stalled and almost caused us to get rear ended. So that along with the inconvenience and danger of dying at stops will push us into performing this costly repair asap. The stalling can occur sometimes at every stop, and sometimes it will not happen for multiple stops. The torque converter is a known issue, and is to be replaced with a more updated model with different internal components. I contacted Subaru and they informed me I was outside of my warranty so it was completely up to me.

- Esko, MN, USA

problem #11

Nov 012015

Legacy

  • 100,000 miles
Vehicle will shudder and stall when coming to a stop most often in the uphill position, it will also stall when coming to a stop after braking hard. This problem is avoided if you place the car in neutral but that is the only way. Engine idle will drop drastically and the vehicle has a hard time reengaging into drive after coming to a complete stop. I assume it is the cvt transmission or the torque convertor.

- Wareham, MA, USA

problem #10

Nov 162016

Legacy

  • 88,000 miles
Issue: When slowing down and then during final braking (such as at a stop sign or traffic light and also when applying the brakes to avoid a dangerous situation at speed on the highway) the car will "shudder" and then the engine will stall and stop running. This is particularly dangerous in traffic if it is necessary to get off the road. The car was brought to brewster, NY Subaru (845 278 8300) and the technician claimed it did not show any codes on the computer. I then asked for a drive with the service manager and then he was able to replicate the issue several times. After never having road tested the car until I asked for it they came back with the guess that it was the torque converter. Cost to fix aprox. $1770.I understand that there was a service bulletin issued on this, but I never received it. I also never received a recall notice. Considering the danger of this fault, I believe there should have been a recall. The car currently has aprox. 88,000 miles. Subaru should be responsible for the repair.

- Brewster, NY, USA

problem #9

Oct 292016

Legacy 4-cyl

  • 111,354 miles
Problem is with the torque converter similar to bulletin number 16-90-13R issued by Subaru involving Legacy and outback models from 2010-2012. My car has been stalling when coming to a hard stop. Just had my car to Firestone and they diagnosed the problem and referenced the bulletin. They recommend taking to a transmission shop or Subaru dealer for repair. As this is a common problem among my car model and year I would have expected to see a recall for this as it is a potentially dangerous condition to stall at lights or stop signs. I believe Subaru should be responsible for these repairs.

- Hazle Township, PA, USA

problem #8

Feb 032016

Legacy 4-cyl

  • miles
A 2010 Subaru Legacy [xxx], 67,381 mi on 02/03/16 was driven approximately 100 yards came to a stop. The vehicle could not be driven forward or reverse. After 30 minutes of attempts of different selection of switches, the vehicle was driven to D dealer. A part, number 22641aa54A sen ay-A/F R was installed to correct the discrepancy. This discrepancy is sufficiently dangerous to warrant a recall. Information redacted pursuant to the Freedom Of Information Act (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6).

- Hudson, WI, USA

problem #7

Mar 012015

Legacy

  • 85,000 miles
When you suddenly brake, the car stalls and engine shuts off. You have to put car in park, and crank the car back on to proceed, which obviously is a safety issue whilst in traffic. This is a known issue according to numerous blogs and websites. This is an issue with a faulty torque converter in Subaru. I even went to the dealer which they admitted it is not a recall but a technical advisory, which due to the safety concern it should be a recall.

- Tampa, FL, USA

problem #6

Oct 012015

Legacy

  • 75,000 miles
Vehicle stalls or engine dies whenever it comes to a complete stop. It happens all day, cold and hot weather. Driver must switch gear from drive to neutral position in order to prevent stalling. This process should not be done on an automatic transmission. No error codes registers on the dash and vehicle starts right away after it stalls. This is an on going problem for Subaru owners base on Subaru forums and threads. Please investigate since this could be a faulty part in transmission and could cause injury, accidents and fatality on drivers.

- South San Francisco, CA, USA

problem #5

Mar 032015

Legacy 4-cyl

  • 79,450 miles
I parked my car after traveling about 100 miles. I was sitting still with the engine running. I have a manual (6 speed) transmission, and the car was in reverse, but the clutch was in all the way and my foot was off the accelerator and on the brake. Suddenly, without any warning, I heard a noise and the engine quickly started to rev and the tachometer went all the way to the red line. After I recovered from the surprise, I tried to kick off the engine by depressing the accelerator quickly and releasing it. My action had no effect. I then turned the engine off with the key and it cut off. I have driven the car today and not had any recurrence of this nor have I had any instance of this type prior to last night.

- Wake Fores, NC, USA

problem #4

Nov 072014

Legacy 4-cyl

  • 110,304 miles
My car stalls when I come to a stop. It is an automatic cvt car. He happens all the time. Could cause an accident when I stop and then accelerate.

- Paxton, MA, USA

problem #3

Nov 142012

Legacy 4-cyl

  • 28,000 miles
Vibrations occur when exceeding 50 mph. These vibrations extend to the steering wheel, floor, and driver and passenger seats and increase as speeds becoming enhanced in speeds over 70mph. No accidents and regular dealer service. Have had multiple balances, alignments and 2 new sets of tires to no avail. Car presently in dealer repair for greater than 8 weeks trying to fix problem. I was informed that the entire front suspension needed to be replaced.

- Millstone Township, NJ, USA

problem #2

Aug 012013

Legacy 4-cyl

  • 65,000 miles
Problems with electronic throttle control or throttle bodys causes the vehicle to hesitate for several seconds upon initial acceleration. This has nearly resulted in accidents on several occasions when merging or pulling out into traffic. Problem of vehicle stalling when stopping at a light started at the same time (related problem). Drives fine under all other conditions. Dealer unable to assist.

- Palm Bay, FL, USA

problem #1

Jan 202010

Legacy 4-cyl

  • 1,000 miles
We purchased the car new, December, 2009. Dealer is over an hour drive from home in another state. Car is pampered and kept in garage when not being used. Just in a couple months developed a pronounced thump in the rear under the car. Intermittent, and there is a feel of the car vibrating or shimmying, if very slightly at the same time. We back out of driveway into street turning wheel to left, straighten, drive forward 80 feet to the stop sign. Accelerate and turn to the right, there is a thump from under the rear of the car. Next stop to the right it doesn't do it. Only at the next turn to the left does it make the same thump. We took everything possible that might roll, out of the car, and it still does it. Cannot seem to duplicate at the dealer. The first service we expressed concern, they looked at it and said they tightened a bushing. They have had the car 4 times since for other issues of rattles and noises, a couple recalls for defective hose and wiring and recently blue-tooth failure which we are still going around with them. They replaced sound deadening in the doors because it harmoniously vibrated at the pitch of scraping finger nails on the chalkboard, and give me the deer in the headlight look when I mention the first service and the term, bushing. When I take coworkers out to lunch, they say, what was that noise (thump), so I know I'm not imagining it. My concern is that something in the suspension is shifting back and forth, side to side, and something is going to fail, causing loss of control or death. Makes me afraid to drive car. 14 months of ownership and we only have 8,650 miles on the car, so it's not like we abuse it.

- Warrenton, OR, USA