10.0

really awful
Crashes / Fires:
4 / 1
Injuries / Deaths:
2 / 0
Average Mileage:
78,599 miles

About These NHTSA Complaints:

The NHTSA is the US gov't agency tasked with vehicle safety. Complaints can be spread across multiple & redundant categories, & are not organized by problem. See the Back button — blue bar at the very top of the page — to explore more.

Get notified about new defects, investigations, recalls & lawsuits for the 2012 Subaru Outback:

Unsubscribe any time. We don't sell/share your email.

« Read the previous 20 complaints

problem #79

Sep 012017

Outback

  • 87,000 miles
The contact owns a 2012 Subaru Outback. The contact stated while driving 10 mph, the vehicle loss motive power without warning while the accelerator pedal was depressed. Additionally, there was also a clunking sound coming from the vehicle. The vehicle was taken to Subaru of san bernardino (645 auto center dr S, san bernardino, ca 92408, (909) 571-5480) and the contact was informed that the vehicle worked as designed. The vehicle was also taken to Subaru of Ontario (1195 auto center dr, Ontario, ca 91761, (909) 487-8325) to be diagnosed. The contact was informed that the transmission and torque converter needed to be replaced. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was contacted and offered to assist with the repair cost. The failure mileage was 87,000.

- Calimesa, CA, USA

problem #78

Dec 192019

Outback 4-cyl

  • 95,000 miles
Intermittent dash lights flashing on my Subaru 2012 Outback, prompted me to take the car in for diagnosis. Subaru is notorious for dash lights flashing when there might be an issue. Brought car in but they could not find issue in about 3 instances.I did the flashing lights reset, but came back on. When lights flash, many other car functions cease, such as cruise control, manual gear function goes inop, etc. Plus flashing lights disguise other issues that may be going on as well (such as brakes), plus very scary in itself. Historically, I am tracking that Subaru has had many issues with this and no time or reason of what could cause these problems or even a solution from them. Subaru finally said I have cvt issue with the torque piece it cause this to slow down in the car and concerned that the whole transmission will go out decide to give them a call trying to get the issue resolve but was told I was out of the warranty!. there was a letter send to me that extended from 60K miles to 100K just recently, but Subaru said my car just missed the warrant work/recall by 4K miles which I think is quite concerning since it has been identified as an issue (recall). Does the issue stop at 100K?

- Layton, UT, USA

problem #77

May 202020

Outback 4-cyl

  • 113,000 miles
Intermittent dash lights flashing on my Subaru 2012 Outback, prompted me to take the car in for diagnosis. Subaru is notorious for dash lights flashing when there might be an issue. Brought car in but they could not find issue. Flashing lights reset, but came back on. When lights flash, many other car functions cease, such as cruise control, manual gear function goes inop, etc. Plus flashing lights disguise other issues that may be going on as well (such as brakes), plus very distracting in itself. Historically, I am tracking Subaru has had many issues with this and no rhyme or reason of what could cause these. Anyhow, Subaru finally said I have a power train issue, bad solenoid that is causing irregular shifting or no shifting to a higher gear. It causes a vibration in the car and concerned that the whole transmission will go out. There was a recall that extended from 60K miles to 100K just recently, but Subaru said my car just missed the warrant work/recall by 14K miles which I think is quite concerning since it has been identified as an issue (recall). Does the issue stop at 100K? I attached the response from Subaru.

- Pc Beach, FL, USA

problem #76

Feb 032020

Outback

  • 114,000 miles
Vehicle shudders and stalls when braking hard. It will not stall on a gradual stop but will stall in any situation when stopping quickly. Does not have to be a panic stop to stall, just hard braking. Resulting stall means loss of power brakes and steering. Have to shift into park and restart vehicle. Has no issues when running or driving. Engine runs vey smooth and has been well maintained as I am the original owner. It is an ongoing issue and repeatable in every circumstance. No computer codes set for this issue. Yet it happens every time there is hard braking which is every time it is driven. This is very dangerous and I am afraid to have my wife and son drive it much less myself.

- Newark, OH, USA

problem #75

Jul 012019

Outback

  • 105,000 miles
The contact's wife owns a 2012 Subaru Outback. The contact stated that while driving and coming to a stop, the vehicle stalled without warning. The vehicle was restarted and operated as designed. The vehicle was taken to miller hill Subaru located at (4710 miller trunk hwy, duluth, mn 55811, (218) 722-5337) to be diagnosed. The contact was informed that the torque converter in the transmission failed and needed to be replaced. The vehicle was repaired. The manufacturer was not made aware of the failure. The approximate failure mileage was 105,000.

- Bemidji, MN, USA

problem #74

Jan 062020

Outback

  • 120,000 miles
Transmission jerks. Then the instrument panel lights are flashing. Trac control, brake loight and cruise light flashing. Check engine light on and will not pass inspection!checked internet and many years and models have same problem. Repair cost of parts alone over $900 happens while accelerating.

- Kenmore, NY, USA

problem #73

Dec 122019

Outback

  • 178,000 miles
Vehicle stalled out several times while driving. Once when braking hard after a car cut in front of me and the second when stopping quickly at a stop light. The car also shutters a little when idling. The dealer says it is the torque converter. I had a $3K transmission repair last year. They said the torque converter would be $1700. The car has 178,000 miles and has regular maintenance. The dealer said it was time to make a decision about a new car. What?! I know in the past these cars would easily make it to 300K miles. This should be a recall.

- Albuquerque, NM, USA

problem #72

Jan 062020

Outback

  • 139,000 miles
The vehicle stalls when coming to a stop. If the accelerator is pushed you can avoid the stall but this is not always feasible. The sudden stall out is very unsafe as it takes putting the vehicle in park, restarting, putting in drive to mobilize the vehicle again.

- Columbia, MD, USA

problem #71

Sep 212018

Outback

  • 70,000 miles
I've been experiencing intermittent issues with the transmission where the vehicle would shudder like it was about to shut off when braking. I've also experienced issues where after starting the vehicle and placing the vehicle into gear, the vehicle would lock up. I took my vehicle to a certified mechanic back in September 2018 who pointed me to a technical service bulletin addressing the same issues I was having: Tsb 16-90-13R, and recommended I go to a Subaru dealership for diagnostics, and repair potentially under extended warranty. I did take my vehicle and get a transmission flush which seemed to alleviate the issue. However, after taking my vehicle to my local Subaru dealership, I was told they could not reproduce the issue, or see any related codes; there doesn't appear to be any record of this issue recorded except for a related warranty request for seat repair. Now that I am experiencing this issue again, I took my vehicle back to the dealer. They gave me the same response and I escalated to soa asking for help getting this transmission repaired. Their response was the same as the dealership's response - that they could not reproduce the issue, and they will not perform the repair. I feel this is a serious issue that could lead to injury or death while operating the vehicle. However, I am still experiencing the issue from time to time, and I do not feel that this vehicle is safe. My wife primarily drives this vehicle to take my children to and from school and other activities. The last time this issue occurred, the vehicle would not start at the gym, and I had to drop everything to go pick up my child from school. My wife was able to restart the vehicle after turning off the vehicle, waiting for a minute, and starting again. This issue seems to occur at low rpms regardless if it is parked, or on city streets or highways.

- Evans, GA, USA

problem #70

Oct 232019

Outback

  • 117,000 miles
When driving on the freeway my transmission suddenly lost power it would intermittently go then stop again. I had a semi right behind me that almost ran over the top of me. As I made it to my exit it began making noise. I drove it straight into my mechanic who thoroughly inspected it and said the transmission had failed.

- Baker City, OR, USA

problem #69

Oct 142019

Outback

  • 156,000 miles
After 7 years of diligent care of my 2012 Outback, my transmission is failing. This is a known issue in my make and model. This will cost me $7K out of pocket to replace. Subaru claims to have 'quality as our highest priority', but did not address this known issue and have put the burden on their customers. This is my third Subaru, and it would be nice if the company stood behind their work and supported their customers

- Carmel, NY, USA

problem #68

Sep 272019

Outback

  • 130,000 miles
My vehicle has been stalling when coming to a stop, it starts to shudder when slowing then stalls at stop. Safety is becoming an issue when in traffic, or on highway in stop and go. There has not been a recall for torque converter issues or cvt transmissions just extended warranty. Unfortunately there were not issues when this was extended. This is on a 2012 Subaru Outback, with 130,000 miles

- Brighton, MI, USA

problem #67

Sep 192019

Outback

  • 164,000 miles
Accelerating from a stopped position, or from a low speed as when making a turn or merging, the vehicle jerks and bucks, comes to a near stall at least once each time, more often 2 or 3 times in quick succession, until the vehicle gains more speed, approximately 10 mph, and the symptoms subside. Vehicle was driven out of necessity a maximum 20 miles on a few days since symptoms began, consistently bucking and near stalling in those conditions, causing traffic disturbances and endangering my family, myself, and other drives on the road. 4 days later the dash lights came on while driving-check engine, flashing emergency brake, traction control, flashing at temp oil-I immediately pulled off the road, bucking and near stalling all the way. Car was towed. Odb-II codes were-transmission control malfunction, and torque converter clutch pressure control solenoid central circuit. Mechanic says can't drive the car. Background checking shows that instead of a recall, a warranty was put in place then due to the extent of the complaints on this, warranty was extended, and Subaru refuses to take appropriate action to resolve this unsafe, expensive, and known issue. There is additionally a sulev emissions warranty which covers this, but it only goes to 150,000 miles and is not a safety issue.

- Stanfordville, NY, USA

problem #66

Jul 292019

Outback

  • 122,000 miles
2012 Subaru Outback with approx. 122,000 miles. The cvt transmission began rasping while under acceleration. Randomly, and over a period of several days, the vehicle stalled, particularly when rapidly decelerating under braking conditions. This required the vehicle to be shifted into park or neutral and restarted. Online, I discovered that there is a rather lengthy history of problems with this Subaru transmission, and that Subaru, apparently to avoid a recall, extended its warranty on the 2012 Outback to July 31, 2018 or 100,000 miles, whichever came first. I was never notified of the warranty extension, a fact that Subaru usa on July 29, 2019 tacitly acknowledge (they said they had no record that I had been notified), but Subaru usa said, despite this, that the warranty date and mileage had now expired and they could do nothing for me. Subaru usa also acknowledged that the estimated repair cost of $9500 was "quite high" and told me that as a "good will" gesture they were prepared to offer me $1500 credit toward the purchase of a new Subaru.

- Springfield, VA, USA

problem #65

Jul 302019

Outback

  • 109,000 miles
My 2012 Subaru Outback engine will shut off when coming to a complete stop when exiting a freeway, coming to a stop on a side street. Speed does not play a factor in this. This happens intermittently and clearly, is a safety issue! I never received a notification on this matter from Subaru that there is a known defect with the torque converter in the transmission. This is something that should have been and still should be a recall. Fatalities could be a result of this! Subaru needs to be held accountable and not just by extending the warranty. Again this is a huge safety isuue!

- Robbinsdale, MN, USA

problem #64

Aug 032019

Outback

  • 130,000 miles
The cvt transmission failed while traveling at a high speed down the interstate with no warning. After doing further research Subaru is very aware of this cvt issues and has taken a very poor and limited approach to stand behind and fix this issue. They told me at the dealership that I was on my own to pay for the repair and it was a 10K fix.

- Mt. Juliet, TN, USA

problem #63

Jun 152019

Outback

  • 133,000 miles
My Outback stalls when coming to a stop. It would do it randomly but now it does it all the time. Subaru won't do anything for me except tell me how much it will cost to fix the torch converter without even checking it on their computer. I have heard of several issues with the cvt and I want to know for sure.

- Antioch, IL, USA

problem #62

Jul 052019

Outback

  • 111,000 miles
While in motion, the cvt transmission suddenly failed without warning. Causing the car to stop forward motion. If this had happened in traffic, it could cause a accident. This is a series safety issue. Cvt transmission is a sealed unit, no serviceable parts. Car is 11K outside warranty. Only repair is 8K replacement.

- Lawrencville, NJ, USA

problem #61

Jun 092019

Outback

  • 175,000 miles
While getting on an off ramp vehicle stalled going 45mph due to the valve body in transmission locking up. Subaru has knowledge of this issue and released a bulletin: 16-90-13R, but only will fix if the issue arises and not before. This issue does not gradually show up but rather happens all at once.

- Mansfield, OH, USA

problem #60

Apr 012019

Outback

  • 146,000 miles
Vehicle shudders when coming to a stop and will stall when going from stopped to motion. Subaru replaced the torque converter 2 years ago and told us this would fix the issue and it did for a little while. The vehicle is now doing the exact same thing--stalling out is a safety issue. Subaru determined that it was once again a faulty/bad torque converter--so this seems like an issue with Subaru torque converters. The first time, they admitted their mistake and paid for the repair. I asked them again to cover it and was even told on the phone by a Subaru representative that the torque converter in a vehicle should not have gone bad the first time, much less the second time...but since my mileage is over their "goodwill" limit for the warranty extension, they will not fully cover the repar/replacement of the torque converter a second time (after having the new one for 2 years, only 45,000 miles.) I know that we are not the only consumers that this is happening too and as it is a known problem with their torque converters and a definite safety issue, my hope is that this will prompt a recall or in some way, have Subaru fix their mistakes and not put it off on the consumer, as if we just happened to purchase a lemon or something.

- Jacksonville, AR, USA

Read the next 20 complaints »