10.0

really awful
Crashes / Fires:
0 / 1
Injuries / Deaths:
0 / 0
Average Mileage:
79,212 miles

About These NHTSA Complaints:

The NHTSA is the US gov't agency tasked with vehicle safety. Complaints can be spread across multiple & redundant categories, & are not organized by problem. See the Back button — blue bar at the very top of the page — to explore more.

Get notified about new defects, investigations, recalls & lawsuits for the 2009 BMW X5:

Unsubscribe any time. We don't sell/share your email.

problem #9

Mar 212023

X5

  • miles
More than one time I have been traveling at regular speed and the vehicle will suddenly power off and shift into Park. While I-??m driving, the battery still has power but the engine shuts off. I am suddenly stopped in the middle of the highway, turning in an intersection, going up a incline. I then try to start the vehicle and it will not turn over. The car remains stuck in park. Eventually the battery wears down and will not even engage the starter. But the lights and flashers will still be on. I have taken the car in multiple times to the bmw dealership telling them of the situation and they tell me it is not showing any problem. The vehicle does not give any warning and there are no engine or warning lights that appear. This happens at any time of day. There are constant complaints of these issues happening with multiple models of bmw.

- Fort Washington, MD, USA

problem #8

Oct 202020

X5

  • 135,000 miles
Car stuck in park and is in fail safe mode also when trying to charge battery while it's dead it sounds like the whole car is clicking

- Cleveland, OH, USA

problem #7

Sep 032019

X5

  • 148,600 miles
I have 2009 BMW X5 xdrive 48I, 148700 mile on it. I am facing a big un safety problems with the malfunction in drive in transmission and AWD and dsc have malfunctioned. This problems on BMW X5 2009 it's from the car and this model exactly and this problem happened with me lat week and the car it start of when I drive it sometimes by it self and didn't know what to do I cannot handle it and I need recall for this to fix it at the dealer near me please

- Pittsburgh, PA, USA

problem #6

Jun 222019

X5

  • 43,886 miles
Bad water pump at 43886 miles. BMW is recalling X5 from 2008 through 2011 but when I called customerelations@bmwusa.com they told me there is no recall on this vehicle. How can BMW calls their vehicles "ultimate driving mechanics" when water pump fails at 43886 miles which cost me $1318.29. Labor cost $803 for less than 1.5 hours work. BMW must acknowledge the water pump failure at low mileage.

- San Jose, CA, USA

problem #5

Jan 242019

X5

  • 103,000 miles
2009 BMW X535D active fuel tank sensor not working

- Avon, CO, USA

problem #4

Sep 022018

X5

  • 85,630 miles
I stopped at a drive thru window and the vehicle shut off without warning. I couldn't get it started and the police tried to put in neutral to move it out of the way. No lights or anything indicated that something was wrong. I have only had the vehicle for 4 days.the airbag restraint light is on and waiting for the sensor. Not sure if this is a recall. It was towed to a shop and then it started when getting it off the tow truck. I don't trust driving it now because it can go out while I'm on the freeway or highway and cause a major accident. There are no reports because I was at a drive thru and just tried to get it out of the way. We had the latest recall done on 08/31/2018.

- Woodland, CA, USA

problem #3

Mar 062018

X5

  • 50,000 miles
My truck BMW parking for more than 6 hours, fire without a known cause, remaining with total loss, I communicated via email with the BMW, after reviewing the internet and find the research done by you, and receiving the possible diagnostic of what happened "an overheating in the pcb valve that rusted and caused the truck to fire", and knowing the bells that are reaping to pick up the vehicles in the United States and Canada, but that they know should be extended to other countries, I put in I know the facts, receiving from them, exactly the BMW group Mexico, the answer that they had no responsibility for these events, because two years ago I did not maintain or wash the engine with them; facts that have nothing to do with the defect of the vehicle. Please ask for your help and collaboration, the incident occurred in cucuta, colombia. The police of my country made an inspection of the events, which resulted in the fact that there was nothing external that had caused the fire, which was the truck alone, which caught on and in very short terms was burned as a total loss. I really understand that this country has rules that can give me a protection, but the BMW is one, and the manufacturer must respond from any point of view, by vehicles that manufacture no matter where they are. Reviewing the models and years to which they are predicted to have this defect, is the X5 series, between the years of manufacture 2007 to 2011, and the truck of my property is X5 - 2009. This is the answer that the BMW invia "dear [xxx] : thank you for contacting the BMW group. Based on your email, we internally review the history of your BMW xdrive30I, VIN [xxx], with factory warranty expired in April 2011. We found a pair of keys reading, which shows lag in the required maintenance services according to factory specifications. Information redacted pursuant to the Freedom Of Information Act (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6).

- Colombia, FL, USA

problem #2

Sep 172015

X5

  • 76,795 miles
I took my vehicle in to BMW service department because I was having problems with my vehicle dry starting (didn't want to start as if it was out of gas). Service guy informed me after he ran a diagnostic check that it was my battery. I was flabbergasted, because that didn't sound of a dead battery. I paid 460 (new battery and diagnostic check) and he assured he ran it again with the new battery and no codes was shown again. Before I even got into my vehicle the Transport guy notice a light on. Service guy checked it out and finds out rear light needs to be replaced, wait a few. Calls me in the back and says we have a big problem, the right tail light wiring harness has burnt and melted the socket and the whole assembly, which will now cost 380 to repair. My husband takes a look at the left side, and it's worst then the right side, which means both sides needs to be repaired. This is a huge safety issue because it could lead to a fire hazard and the owner would bot even know it. The service guy said he ran a check before and after the replacement of the new battery all within 24hrs, and it didn't it catch this huge safety issue that has been going on in my vehicle, which is naked to the eye unless someone opens up those departments and look with a flash light. Please be aware and lets get this resolved.

- Orlando, FL, USA

problem #1

Mar 262013

X5 6-cyl

  • 70,000 miles
When let go of brake after stopping at red light, very often that this vehicle makes a suddent jump. This happens so often that cause a safety concern.

- Missouri City, TX, USA