10.0

really awful
Crashes / Fires:
1 / 0
Injuries / Deaths:
2 / 0
Average Mileage:
67,182 miles

About These NHTSA Complaints:

The NHTSA is the US gov't agency tasked with vehicle safety. Complaints can be spread across multiple & redundant categories, & are not organized by problem. See the Back button — blue bar at the very top of the page — to explore more.

Get notified about new defects, investigations, recalls & lawsuits for the 2005 Ford Five Hundred:

Unsubscribe any time. We don't sell/share your email.

problem #11

Nov 102022

Five Hundred

  • miles
I have 2 very serious and dangerous issues. The 1st issue, the car will shut off while driving and without warning. I'll be cruzing down the highway and out of no where it shuts off. I then do not have breaks or power stearing. This last Winter my daughter was driving it and it shut off while she was on black ice. The car flew into the ditch and the snow was so deep it was compacted in the entire engine so it was impossible to restart the car. It was akso -37 below temperature. It took me almost a half hour to get to her and she almost froze to death. She sustained frost bite on her hands, toes, ears, and cheeks. She almost died. Issue 2, my daughter was driving and all of the sudden a loud noise and she couldn't steer. The rear control arm bracket that is part of the subframe busted causing the control arm to no longer be attached to the frame. She almost flipped the car when that happened. I looked into it and many cars this year make and model had the exact same thing happen in the exact same spot. So that tells me that it is a manufacturer defect. I had this looked at and inspected by Trusted Tires & Auto. Neither of these issues had any warning at all. So now the car sits unable to be driven. Even if it was fixed I won't drive it or let my daughter drive it and I can't sell it because I don't want anyone else to drive it period. It is a death trap literally and puts everyone's life in dangernear that come near the car. It needs to be recalled immediately. This is absolutely unacceptable and Ford needs to stand behind their product. If this car continues to stay on the roads Many people will die because of all the defects on the car.

- Minot, ND, USA

problem #10

Jul 082023

Five Hundred

  • miles
While driving the front end suspension slips, bounces up and down very harshly, tires slip, squeak, and slide in an hard to control way, sometimes into oncoming traffic when in slightly damp conditions an on roads with any amount of bumps, to the point that I need to drive extremely slow to avoid danger which in turn puts my and my passengers and my kids in danger by goin to slow in regards to the traffic around us. When hitting relatively small bumps the suspension bounces the car severely up and down and across the road into harms way.

- South Bend , IN, USA

problem #9

Feb 072020

Five Hundred

  • 0 miles
I was driving my car it started to shake very hard well I heard a snap sound and my car started to drag I got out my frame above my right lower control had snapped ive read that many other people are having the same problem I contactes Ford about the issue and they said there is nothing they can do well I'm out of a vehicle but vefore all of this I kept going through fuel relay issues and eventually started losing my instrument cluster so now I'm fighting with them to do the repairs

- Frankfort, WV, USA

problem #8

May 162019

Five Hundred

  • 136,000 miles
Suspension: Continuous rattle issues in the rear suspension. Bushings" sway bars?? who knows. No one can seem to pinpoint the problem. Happens only during driving. Consistent noise from the rear. Fuel: Problems with fuel sensor. Failed reading. All gauges light up. Run obd and all fluid levels / pressure fine. No reason for the failure. Dealership told me the throttle body was an issue and the sensor inside same. However, after numerous web based searches I found that throttle body issues are definitely an issue. Found that removing the air cleaner box for filter replacement can cause sensor issues. Why" since my last oil change I have had at least three failures here. This is dangerous, expensive and should be taken care of.

- Kalamazoo, MI, USA

problem #7

Apr 242017

Five Hundred

  • 173,000 miles
Track bar bracket on the exit from my driveway to the road the car started to drive erratically. After stopping the car and investigation I found that rear right track bar bracket is completely detached from the car body. It looks like a complete structure failure. Fortunately, the failure happened at very low speed and no one was harmed. Photos of the car are enclosed.

- Potsdam, NY, USA

problem #6

Feb 212017

Five Hundred

  • 295,000 miles
Front driver side lower control arm ball joint sheared off at 25 mph while making a left hand turn and then snapped the cv joint axle shaft causing the driver side wheel to jam inside the wheel well and damage lower part of body and fender. The vehicl was totally disable at this point sitting in the middle of an intersection. Similar incident happened two years ago with the passenger side front wheel and the lower control arm ball joint sheared and snapped the cv joint axle shaft at 45 mph and caused vehicle to turn 180 degrees blocking two lanes of hwy. That time front wheel damaged wheel well and sensor wires on that side fo the engine bay

- Memphis, TN, USA

problem #5

Jan 132013

Five Hundred 6-cyl

  • 130,000 miles
Rear upper control arm sheared off at inside bushings during normal driving. Wheel assembly fell against frame and some loss of control was experienced. Both sides of control arm (Ford part# 5A804) broke off from fatigue.

- Dahlonega, GA, USA

problem #4

Aug 052005

Five Hundred

  • 0 miles
Tsb 10-2-13. I have inner rear tire wear, especially on the right (this likely existed when purchased new). There is a tsb that talks about some cars with rr negative camber, (which my car does have), and also talks about how to modify the rear control arm to remedy the problem. The danger in this defect is a blowout of a tire or tires while driving. Car is immaculate. I bought it new and take great care of it. This is obviously a defect given how many other owners are commenting it on-line via forums. Also, there is a tsb on it, so Ford is aware of it. Even though they should take care of it since it is a defect, they won't. Ford, even with all their hype on quality and safety as job one, are just a bunch of hypocrites. They act only when forced to do so by you folks at the federal level. I'm old school. It's all about integrity for me. Why do you think Ford still lives up to their reputation as fix or repair daily. Had a similar issue with the rear brakes several years ago on this vehicle. I took it for Ford and they would not own up to it until I complained to you folks like many other did and they finally reimbursed us because of your intervention. Again, they always have to be forced to do the right thing! just a bunch of thugs. Where is elliot ness when you need him! 02/15/10. Suspension - rear tire inner edge wear Ford: 2005-2007 Five hundred, freestyle, 2008-2009 Taurus X, Taurus.

- Munhall, PA, USA

problem #3

Jun 032011

Five Hundred 6-cyl

  • miles
The vehicle lunges while holding the brake when putting into reverse or drive and continues to do so while waiting to pull into traffic making it very dangerous! it also does this while trying to park making it dangerous to park near anything! I have seen several complaints regarding this very same problem stating it is a throttle body defect that costs at lowest $700 to repair. Front suspension is shot already with loud clunking noises, very rough ride! rear doors fill with water which will result in rust holes! all of these problems have been reported several times by other owners of this same year and make of vehicle. Ford should be responsible for the repairs needed to fix these problems.

- Warren, MI, USA

problem #2

Jan 112006

Five Hundred 6-cyl

  • Automatic transmission
  • 1,500 miles
Vibration on right front of car during speeds of 55 mph to 62 mp. Replaced Continental tires with Michelin and vibration still occurs.

- Kevil, KY, USA

problem #1

Jun 152005

Five Hundred 4-cyl

  • Automatic transmission
  • 3,500 miles
Continuation of suspension and brake problems after last filing with NHTSA. Braking in wet weather, descending steep grade, car pulls and fades. 2 days after longmont Ford had car for 6 days and returned it with clean bill of health. Omera Ford diagnosed brake and transmission programming problems and once again turned down rear rotors to very close to minimum specifications. Consumer report Jan 2005 reports similar issues with braking, auto-week may-16-2005 reports brake fade and stability problems in their test track report. This is a first model year car for Ford which is based off of a modified Volvo design of under-carriage. The vehicle is now parked with an affidavit of non use on it because of the number of incidents and repairs that have occurred on rear suspension and brakes. Ford at arbitration maintained that in late July there were more tsb's issued for the 2005 Ford 500, but I am unable to find same on NHTSA website. With the number of independent trade and consumer publications that site the same issues that I am having with this car, I petition NHTSA to pull some of these early model cars and subject them to suspension and braking test as stated in NHTSA 99.6583-1 consumer braking information initiative, aberdeen test center fall 1998.

- Longmont, CO, USA