10.0

really awful
Crashes / Fires:
4 / 2
Injuries / Deaths:
2 / 0
Average Mileage:
12,148 miles

About These NHTSA Complaints:

The NHTSA is the US gov't agency tasked with vehicle safety. Complaints can be spread across multiple & redundant categories, & are not organized by problem. See the Back button — blue bar at the very top of the page — to explore more.

Get notified about new defects, investigations, recalls & lawsuits for the 2016 Mazda CX-5:

Unsubscribe any time. We don't sell/share your email.

problem #28

Sep 172023

CX-5

  • miles
Catastrophic engine failure. Needs a total engine replacement, regular oil changes. We went to get the oil changed within 1,000 miles of the suggested mileage range and it was -??out of oil-??. The dealership told us we needed a new engine. It hasn-??t been driven and sounds like a helicopter when turned on. We have had regular maintenance on the vehicle, one owner. It started acting up and was trying to stall out on the highway. Then seized up and wouldn-??t go over 10mph. It-??s totaled and we feel strongly that this is an extension of the current lawsuit covering many years of Mazda models.

- Riverside, MO, USA

problem #27

Jun 072024

CX-5

  • miles
My daughter was driving her 2016 CX5 when the coolant temperature warning message displayed on the instrument panel, advising her to pull over immediately. She had just driven on to the expressway, but luckily was still in the right lane and was able to pull over safely. If she had been in any other lane of the busy highway when this occurred it could have been a serious safety issue for my daughter and the other drivers on the highway. I contacted AAA to tow the car to my local mechanic. The service tech reported that they began by plugging their diagnostic tool into the car and they received two engine codes: P111A-00 and P011A, and that a software update must be performed first. I had the car towed to Turnersville Mazda. They said that there would be a $215 per hour diagnostic fee. They found that the thermostat needed to be replaced as it failed to open during engine operation. This service incurred a $397.55 cost. After replacing it they noticed that a milky substance was produced, indicating motor oil mixing with coolant. They recommended replacing the engine due to a crack in the cylinder head at a cost of $10,300. For some reason the service tech elected to replace the spark plugs and update the software AFTER the catastrophic engine issue was discovered, incurring an additional $330 in charges. Prior to this incident there were no issues with the vehicle, no warning lamps or symptoms of any kind.

- Cherry Hill, NJ, USA

problem #26

Jun 112024

CX-5

  • miles
Bolt from inside engine blew out, putting hole in engine block

- Tomball, TX, USA

problem #25

May 262024

CX-5

  • miles
Car was having trouble with pickup and was making a subtle recurrent noise. Sped up after turning a corner and engine just sputtered out and car came to a complete stop within seconds. The engine light never came on and the engine did not overheat. Car would not turnover to start after that. Car was towed to an independent garage where they stated engine failure. Was then towed to a garage that can handle engine issues where it was declared a total loss and catastrophic engine failure.

- Oak Ridge, NJ, USA

problem #24

Jan 182023

CX-5

  • miles
Changed my oil and the next day the engine blew, maintained exactly how the manufacturer suggests, but somehow the engine blew.

- West Valley City, UT, USA

problem #23

Feb 052024

CX-5

  • miles
First symptom, no heat coming out of heater vent took to shop to investigate and found antifreeze in the oil. Cylinder head removed and found a nonreparable crack In the cylinder head. I'll maintenance up todaye, Engine never overheated, no symptoms, just suddenly Blowing cold air from the heat vent. $7300 estimate 2 fix.

- Grand Ledge, MI, USA

problem #22

Nov 042022

CX-5

  • miles
The check engine light came on when I was in my way home. This morning when I started my car, the engine reved on its own and then it went to 0. This is super dangerous. The car could have stopped in the middle of the freeway. I had my car towed to a local mechanic. The error code that came up was p0192. Looks like there is a recall for the fuel pump issue for many mazda, yet mine isn-??t part of it.

- Monterey Park, CA, USA

problem #21

Oct 042022

CX-5 4-cyl

  • miles
Car: 2018 Mazda CX-5 Touring with approximately 39,000 miles. Issue: Burning smell coming from engine compartment- Oil leaking from engine. Problem: Cracked cylinder head as diagnosed by dealer and to be replaced under Mazda Power Train Warranty. Safety was a concern not knowing the issue. Concerned of engine failure, fire, and overall safety. Warnings: No warnings or check engine light was also concerning. Time frame: 10/1/22 evening- noticed slight burning smell which lasted only a few minutes. No evidence of oil leaking. - 10/2/22: Slight burning smell occurred briefly on and off through out late afternoon. No evidence of oil leaking. Smell dissipated. - 10/3/22: Stronger presence of burning smell. Started to notice oil leaking from under car. - 10/4/22: Car inspected by local mechanic and advised to bring to dealer for further assessment. Mechanic observed increased oil leakage and stated oil was coming from within engine. Car towed to dealer, evaluated with a cracked cylinder head. Repair to be covered under Mazda Power Train Warranty. Additional concern: Short and Long Term residual effects on other engine components. Other reports: none. Awareness: I-??ve come to understand that there seems to be similar issues with certain model years/production runs that might not be reported due to being covered under warranty. The consumer provided the correct VIN for the vehicle.

- Denville , NJ, USA

problem #20

Aug 182022

CX-5

  • miles
While driving to the airport suddenly all dashboard lights came on and engine "died" during the drive about 50mph. My wife who was driving, was lucky not to get into a crash and steered the car to the side to a full stop. The tow truck driver tried to restart the engine w/o success. The garage determined it is a catastrophic engine failure and need to be replaced. About 2 weeks prior we had an engine warning light. The car was taken to our regular serviced garage and was inspected w/o any issues and light was reset. All routing maintenance has been performed by same garage. There are similar reports on the web about total engine failure of Mazda CX5 during driving!!!

- Carlsbad, CA, USA

problem #19

May 092022

CX-5

  • miles
I own a 2016 Mazda CX-5 Touring with AWD. I purchased it brand new from a dealer--no miles on it. It's been a great car until this Sudden Unintended Acceleration problem (about 60K miles now). It's happened 5 or 6 times--twice when in a drive thru. It seems that if I am idling (not pressing on gas or brake) the car will sometimes suddenly accelerate. I have used suggestions to brake, then place car in neutral. That seemed to resolve the problem. However, recently I pulled up to my (rural) mailbox and the car tried to accelerate out of control. I had the brake on (was on a downhill) when it happened, so this was scary. I really had to press down more on the brake pedal, then shifted to neutral, then to park. The acceleration finally stopped. I did not observe tachometer readings during this or other events, but will pay more attention if/when this happens in the future. I do not drive with both feet, and as these incidents have occurred I have been able to maintain more composure and analyze what is going on. I am not getting my foot caught in the mat and I'm not mistakenly pressing on the accelerator. I've been to my local Mazda dealer (Sport Durst in Durham) on May 13, 2022 and they were unable to replicate the problem, so could not repair or even troubleshoot it. The car was T-boned about a year ago, with some damage to the passenger front tire. Could that have anything to do with my problems? My partner feels this could be an issue with the Throttle Control Sensor (hardware) or with the software managing throttle control (much more difficult to diagnose, he says). I wanted to ask: for anyone experiencing this problem, did replacing the Throttle Control Sensor or diagnosing software problems resolve the issue" And, do you have any recommendations for me" Since the car is (barely) out of warranty, (just over 6 yrs/60,000 miles) would filing a claim with Mazda be a good approach" Would you suggest I just trade the car in"

- Chapel Hill, NC, USA

problem #18

Jun 192019

CX-5

  • 50,000 miles
The contact owns a 2016 Mazda CX-5. The contact stated that upon depression of the brake pedal, the engine revved violently without warning. The contact would depress the brake pedal to the floorboard and place the vehicle into park(P) to prevent the vehicle from independently accelerating. The contact had taken the vehicle to a dealer and was informed that the air box was defective. The dealer repaired the vehicle; however, the failure recurred. The manufacturer was not notified of the failure. The vehicle was not repaired. The failure mileage was approximately 50,000.

- Medford, NJ, USA

problem #17

Jul 302021

CX-5

  • miles
My problem is with the keyless start system. The problem is that if I forget to push the start button to shut down the vehicle and open the door and leave the automobile and shut the door with the key in my possession the auto will keep running until it runs out of fuel. Wouldn't it make more sense for the vehicle to shut down after 3 minutes if the key is not present. As you know people have died from carbon monoxide poisoning by parking in their garage and forgetting to shut down the vehicle and the vehicle keeps running and filling their homes with carbon monoxide. This happened to a older couple in Sarasota Florida with a new car that they just purchased and were not familiar with the starting system. Just wanted to know just how many people have to die before something is done about this problem. I asked my Mazda dealer and they told me that the vehicle will run until out of fuel and basically said that I was stupid for being concerned.

- Sarasota , FL, USA

problem #16

Jul 202021

CX-5

  • miles
Original belt tensioner was failing at 50k miles. An oem mazda belt tensioner was installed and is failing again within 1 year at 67k miles. If this fails the belt powering the water pump will fail causing a catastrophic engine failure due to overheating. Mazda has yet to issue a recall with their defective parts. If you hear any squeaking of the belts from your engine and notice any residue leaking from the tensioner get it replaced ASAP or your car could become a hazard.

- Dayton, OH, USA

problem #15

Jun 142021

CX-5

  • miles
Dealer identified drive belt tensioner as leaking and in need of replacement on a Mazda CX-5 with less than 30k miles on it. Many owners have reported identical failures at or around 30k. An insufficient part that is failing so frequently, this early on with low mileage is a significant safety issue.

- Campbell, CA, USA

problem #14

Nov 282020

CX-5

  • 30,020 miles
High pressure fuel pump failure. Vehicle mileage 30,020. Check engine light illuminated, vehicle would not start. Replacement cost 920.60.

- Lighthouse Point, FL, USA

problem #13

Nov 292020

CX-5

  • 53,824 miles
During a routine inspection by the dealer following an oil change the mechanic discovered that the drive belt tensioner had begun to leak and if not replaced (at $400) will cause the engine to fail and will strand motorist. Current mileage 53, 824. With little effort I discovered that this is a well-known problem with this vehicle with many failing at around the 30K mile mark. Looks like a design flaw that Mazda usa is passing onto the consumer.

- Livermore, CA, USA

problem #12

Apr 252020

CX-5

  • 45,591 miles
I went to the dealership and they informed me that the hydraulic belt tensioner was leaking. They quoted me $400 for repair and stated this is a wear item yet the manual and user guide provided by Mazda do not state that this is required to be replaced only inspected. My car has less then 46,000 miles and this part was nearly at the point of failure. If this part fails and the belt gets too loose or snaps, your car will shut down. Essentially, if that belt breaks, your alternator will stop charging the battery, the dash will light up like a christmas tree, and the car will sputter to a complete stop. Not to mention the fact that the belt also turns the water pump. So while the car could shut down in order to avoid overheating. Mazda has stated they will not cover this as it's out of warranty for a what should be considered a defective part. If you hear knocking sounds from your engine get your vehicle inspected asap!

- Baltimore, MD, USA

problem #11

Oct 202018

CX-5

  • 62,000 miles
The contact owns a 2016 Mazda Cx-5. while driving 65 mph, there was a popping noise and black smoke coming from the engine compartment. All the warning indicators illuminated on the instrument panel. The contact coasted the vehicle over to the side of the road and heard another popping noise. The contact then noticed flames under the hood. The contact extinguished the fire himself. The vehicle was towed to capitol Mazda (located at 980 capitol expressway auto mall, san jose, ca 95136, (408) 763-4018) where it was diagnosed that the engine block failed and the engine rod was fractured. The dealer stated that the engine needed to be replaced. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was notified of the failure and provided case number: 1-1844061638. The approximate failure mileage was 62,000.

- Phoenix, AZ, USA

problem #10

Feb 102019

CX-5

  • 28,350 miles
Started car in driveway 2/10/19, 4 pm 'engine sounded like timing was obviously abnormal. Random automatic braking noted when car in motion, within one block of leaving driveway. Immediate inability to accelerate beyond 10-12 mph experienced. Error messages then observed on car dashboard warning sectors: Check engine; traction control: Tire pressure monitoring; smart city brake support malfunction-forward scbs disabled. Car unsafe to drive to dealer 12 miles away. Car towed to dealer site 2/11/19 Monday am. Car has 28,330 miles per odometer; service maintenance up to date, as manufacturer recommended. Dealer assessment of cause on 2/11/19 reported as 'rats nesting in engine and eating through soy insultation on wiring on engine harness.' Repair costs of > $1,500 estimated. It seems that insulating engine component with nutrients attractive to nesting, ubiquitous vermin is a serious safety concern for car owners and users. Any NHTSA guidance on this critical issue?

- Novato, CA, USA

problem #9

Sep 222018

CX-5

  • miles
In a parking space, foot on brake, moving gearshift to park, engine revved and car lunged forward with car in park and my foot on the brake. It jumped the concrete bumper, ran over handicap parking sign and hit car in adjacent parking space hard enough to move it back into the driving lane of parking lot. At that point the car stopped. We pulled it back into parking space to help move other hit car out of traffic

- Dallas, TX, USA

Read the next 8 complaints »